Best board games and tabletop RPGs of 2021

It’s been one other unusual 12 months for followers of tabletop video games. Just as COVID restrictions had been relaxed in lots of communities, the worldwide provide chain broke down. Games that had been extremely anticipated in January merely failed to indicate up with backers or on retailer cabinets by the top of the 12 months. But that’s to not say it’s been slim pickings — not by a protracted shot.

In-person gaming did choose up a bit this 12 months. Smaller board video games that may in any other case have been missed acquired a lift, with higher-profile titles pushed again into 2022. The end result was a good movement of consumers for native sport shops, lots of which have managed to bounce again after months of being locked down. Even the conference circuit is springing again to life in safer methods, with occasions like PAX Unplugged requiring proof of vaccination and masking always.

Digital distribution was additionally an enormous a part of 2021. Independent creators of tabletop RPGs (TTRPGs) ended up in the perfect place, with platforms like itch.io and DriveThruRPG letting them attain their viewers in respectable numbers. Platforms like Tabletop Simulator, Board Game Arena, and different on-line companies continued to permit followers to get collectively. Meanwhile, Roll20, Fantasy Grounds, and Foundry VTT facilitated the vital work of conserving campaigns rolling into the brand new 12 months.

But not like nearly all of fashionable video video games, board video games and tabletop RPGs have unusually lengthy lives. I discovered myself dusting off previous favorites to share them with the household for the very first time. Your dusty hallway closet could make room for some actual treasures, too — particularly if you happen to take the time to curate it occasionally. That’s why Polygon requested greater than 20 writers, designers, presenters, actors, and personalities from around the globe of tabletop gaming to inform us which video games helped to make their 12 months a bit brighter. Here’s what we discovered.

---

Author (Gaunt’s Ghosts, the Eisenhorn trilogy) and co-writer of Warhammer 40,000: Darktide

Image: Fatshark

Thanks to the pandemic, I’ve most likely spent extra time this final 12 months re-reading favourite RPG dietary supplements — Traveller, Dungeons & Dragons, Runequest, Call of Cthulhu and so forth — fairly than taking part in something tabletop. But I’ve change into a fan of CMON’s Cthulhu: Death May Die for that fast horror repair. Easy to play, quick to arrange, and with superb manufacturing high quality, particularly the minis. It’s nice technique to seize that Cthulhu vibe once you don’t have the time or alternative for a serious, complicated RPG marketing campaign. I ought to play extra issues typically, however I do know what I’m like — if I performed extra, I’d by no means get any writing finished.

---

Game designer, present challenge Critical Care

Kabuto Sumo is the sport that completely knocked me on my ass this 12 months. I missed the Kickstarter like a dork. Then earlier than I knew it I used to be being stared down by a tower of Kabuto Sumo video games at Origins Game Fair and made positive I snapped up a duplicate. I left that conference one delightfully beautiful and critically enjoyable sport richer.

Kabuto Sumo is about sumo wrestling beetles and performs one thing like that coin pushing sport we had been all obsessive about on the arcade however weren’t allowed to play as a result of it’s not a sound monetary funding. Pushing effectively crafted picket shapes round to attempt to knock your opponent off a cardboard platform makes for an excellent sport on it’s personal, however you additionally get to select your beetle wrestler (I take advantage of Sisyphus the Dung Beetle — typically only for the poop jokes), which comes with a particular picket piece to push round and a singular capacity or two. Ultimately, this implies if you happen to’re very petty you will discover a technique to accumulate your opponent’s distinctive merchandise and knock them off the board with it. My good friend was past livid that I’d do such a factor and I wouldn’t be capable to reside with myself if I didn’t.

---

Aker Bharadvaj

Designer of Zenobia Award first-place winner, Tyranny of Blood

I take pleasure in video games that mannequin battle throughout totally different domains. War video games are inclined to concentrate on the battlefield, however conflict happens elsewhere concurrently: inside spiritual texts, {the marketplace}, the classroom, the manufacturing unit ground, and on the treaty negotiation desk.

Versailles 1919 fashions the final of those. Britain, France, Italy, and the United States carve up the Central Powers after World War I, doubtlessly ushering in an period of freedom and self-determination… or one in all German humiliation and imperial abuse. You resolve on points that have an effect on hundreds of thousands overseas — who might violently resist — whereas sustaining your home as a worldwide energy and assuaging home pressures.

It often is the solely sport I’ve performed the place you sit round a desk making tough technique choices, taking part in others who additionally sat round a desk making tough technique choices. This meta-narrative lends the expertise a darkish humor; one imagines Georges Clemenceau and David Lloyd George pushing cubes and dealing playing cards, squeezing victory factors out of the newly drawn Iraq-Syria border with out contemplating the violent penalties for the locals in 1919, a lot much less in 2021.

Such is the irony of imperial energy. Peace might be as bloody and disruptive as conflict. You can single-handedly decide a future for the individuals of Banat, with out figuring out the place Banat even is. You can sit in a Hall of Mirrors for six months with out reflecting by yourself imperial excesses. Versailles 1919 allows you to remake that collection of choices that birthed the final century, for higher or for worse.

---

Video goblin at Shut Up & Sit Down

Image: Shut Up & Sit Down/YouTube

Oh goodness, it’s simply too imply. No Thanks! is perhaps the proper festive sport as a result of it allows you to sow precisely the correct quantity of dissent and spite with out sprawling itself over a number of sluggish hours — it’s quick, simple, and painful. Players are primarily participating in round-robin auctions of how a lot they don’t need a card — with the winner (loser?) of stated public sale taking the cardboard, and that many factors with it. But on this sport, factors are actual unhealthy — the participant with essentially the most of them dropping the sport — and to make issues worse, these tokens you’re frittering away for the privilege of claiming “No Thanks!” to a nasty excessive card really offer you unfavourable factors if you happen to maintain onto them till the top.

But pay attention; there are about three extra guidelines in your entire sport — making it fantastically simple to show, instantly enjoyable and brief sufficient to crank it up once more as soon as everybody is aware of what they’re doing. But what’s actually on this field is potential — a sport the place the foundations are so easy however the implications of them daybreak on each participant organically. At its very worst? It’s pleasant. At its finest? It’ll foster a love of that “click” second current in solely the perfect boardgames — having your giftee sheepishly ask, “Have you got anything more like that?”

---

YouTube persona and voice-over actor

During quarantine occasions, I foolishly collected a stockpile of legacy video games, unable to do nothing however stare at them sadly and want I might see my buddies once more. Now that I’m capable of have common sport nights once more, my buddies and I’ve been devouring Clank! Legacy: Acquisitions Incorporated. I do know nothing in regards to the Acquisitions Incorporated property, however Clank! and Clank! In Space! have been common fixtures on my sport shelf. And as a legacy sport, this one’s really unbelievable.

Retaining the deck-building gameplay that permits you to transfer by the board and accumulate artifacts and rewards, Clank! Legacy introduces quests and targets that you simply and your fellow adventurers can fulfill and in consequence unlock new content material that you simply learn from an enormous Book of Secrets that provides new lore and extra importantly, new, enjoyable mechanics and rewards. It takes a sport that was all about cutthroat racing and turns it into a extremely participating semi-cooperative sport.

With my group, we’re adamant about unlocking as lots of the secrets and techniques as effectively as potential, so we are going to strategize and formulate sport plans to make sure we get these goodies. At the identical time, the sport nonetheless has that satisfaction of grabbing juicy playing cards and gadgets that let you exhibit some spectacular performs. I’ve not laughed as arduous and loved a bunch expertise this a lot in a very long time, so if you happen to’re a fan of Clank! and/or legacy video games, this one’s good shit.

---

Co-designer of Descent: Legends of the Dark

A Mending by Shing Yin Khor is a sport about taking a visit to see a good friend that you simply haven’t seen in a while. It’s additionally a sport about creating a singular murals, and the inventive collaboration between sport designer and participant. In the annoying and sometimes lonely years of COVID, A Mending is a mild reassurance that relationships and creativity nonetheless keep it up.

A Mending performs over an illustrated map that’s damaged right into a grid. As you play, you completely embellish the map by stitching or drawing on it. I play on the sport’s material map utilizing my novice needlecraft information, horde of rummage sale buttons, and low cost embroidery floss, however the sport additionally comes with two paper maps. As you play, you discover who your character is, your relationship to your long-separated good friend, and the occasions of your journey. Games are an artwork, and A Mending provides you the visible manifestation: every play by is an expression of creativity that provides to your map, turning it right into a singular, displayable murals. One you possibly can share once you subsequent take the journey to see your mates in actual life.

---

Actress and improviser, Things Get Dicey and Watch It Played

My prime sport of 2020 was the co-op trick-taking sport The Crew: Quest for Planet Nine and in 2021 they got here out with a comply with up that’s one way or the other even higher! The Crew: Mission Deep Sea streamlined and simplified among the guidelines in Quest for Planet Nine making the sport much more approachable than it already was, and likewise making it one in all my favourite video games I’ve performed this 12 months.

I grew up taking part in Spades and that gave me an actual love for trick-taking video games. The Crew is absolutely cooperative — you’re a staff working collectively to win tips, however each spherical every participant is assigned particular duties they’ve to finish. These duties is perhaps one thing like “win the most pink cards” or “win a trick using a card with value one.” To win the spherical, everybody should succeed of their duties. But right here’s the kicker — you aren’t allowed to speak about what playing cards you’ve got in your hand! That could make creating the precise state of affairs you might want to full your job a bit … difficult (pun absolutely supposed).

Sometimes the rounds are actually tough to win and also you repeat them again and again … however that second when the playing cards align and also you sync up mentally as a staff and lastly play all the pieces good to finish that job you’ve been failing repeatedly — effectively, nothing beats that feeling of communal triumph. The Crew has given me a few of my favourite, exuberant gaming moments with my buddies and truthfully, helped me keep linked to them by the distancing of the pandemic. And sure, you possibly can play it digitally on platforms like Board Game Arena!

---

Hunter Donaldson and Matt Martens

Space Cats Peace Turtles podcast

Photo: Space Cats Peace Turtles

We’d performed plenty of Twilight Imperium, and we’d grown used to the sorts of tales it might inform. Then, November of 2020 introduced us it’s first (and seemingly solely) growth, Twilight Imperium: Prophecy of Kings. It’s a dear addition to a dear sport, but it surely’s a drastic shift to the tales gamers have come to know and love.

The major modifications add tons of taste to the early sport (i.e. the primary 3-4 hours), however what they add definitely takes away one thing gamers cherished about base sport’s conclusions. Exploration, the unlocking of highly effective skills, more cash, and sooner ships: all of this stuff end in extra interplay between gamers. But when it comes time to crown a winner, plans might be upended and probability can dictate destiny to such an extent that essentially the most dependable path to victory is much less in regards to the techniques you’ve chosen and extra in regards to the allies you’ve made alongside the way in which.

Much like true conquest, you will need to work together with your combatants as typically as in opposition to them. Now, the tales we inform are wealthy with exploits and betrayals, alongside the talk about whether or not or not the winner really deserves their crown.

---

Creative director, head of publishing at Possum Creek Games, creator of Wanderhome

Under Hollow Hills is the form of sport that modifications you. It has a sure approach about it, this circus sport of faeries beneath the hole hills, the identical form of anonymous contact that’s carried on autumn winds or perched behind ruins on the fringe of city. It is faerie-kind, bewitching and delightful.

Every time I play it, Under Hollow Hills teaches me one thing new. One day it’s about summer time and winter, how I’m when I’m heat and the way I’m when my coronary heart grows chilly, how my gender modifications with the seasons. Another session teaches me vulnerability, how the Nightmare Horse in all his energy seems so mild and tender in my fingers when he asks for me to carry him. Under Hollow Hills is a sport about how we deal with one another when occasions are good and the way we deal with one another when occasions are unhealthy — between its beautiful prose, fascinating imaginative characters, numerous treasures, and pure flowing play fashion, Under Hollow Hills is the way forward for tabletop role-playing video games, a singular and unattainable treasure.

---

Artist at Leder Games, writer of Root and Oath

Honestly one in all my favourite gaming experiences this 12 months was educating a few of my prolonged household the right way to play Skull on every week lengthy tenting journey. I discovered the right way to play Skull on-line and I’ve solely ever performed it with face playing cards and pony beads to maintain observe of factors. I performed most likely 30 occasions over the course of week by lantern gentle and underneath collapsible awnings when it rained. By Friday a few of my youthful cousins had been taking part in Skull with out me and it was fairly widespread to stroll as much as a full desk of individuals taking part in it, nowhere to take a seat!

I believe it’s most likely my favourite bluffing sport as a result of it’s so distilled — simply pure bluffing. It additionally scales rather well with a number of individuals, so it’s good for households and even my children as a result of you possibly can play with out absolutely understanding the foundations and study as you go.

---

Tabletop editor, Polygon

It’s been a protracted whereas since I contributed to a crowdfunding marketing campaign, however when the reboot of HeroQuest was introduced in 2020, I used to be all in. The dungeon crawling board sport was an enormous a part of my childhood, and I nonetheless take pleasure in taking part in that authentic copy with my daughters to today.

I can’t specific to you the enjoyment that I felt as my 8-year-old reached deep into the large brown field of goodies that arrived together with my top-tier pledge. “There’s girls in here, dad! I can play your favorite board game with someone who looks like me!” And so we did … so much.

Deena the elf and Lucy the wizard have been traipsing by the grimdark halls alongside my Bill the barbarian and Foskor the dwarf. Behind the sport grasp’s display screen? My oldest daughter, taking part in the mighty Zargon. We’ve rescued Sir Ragnar, fought a lethal gargoyle, and extra. Thanks to the three all-new campaigns that got here bundled with my early pledge, there are a lot of extra adventures but to return.

Co-founder of Polygon, co-creator of The Adventure Zone and My Brother, My Brother, and Me

As a board sport fan in a pandemic who additionally has entry to younger kids (they’re mine, not on mortgage or employed or something) I’m continuously searching for accessible video games for teenagers which might be nonetheless fulfilling for me, a discerning grownup. I discovered a stellar a kind of in Beasts of Balance. It’s a digital/bodily sport hybrid the place you create a (actually) balanced ecosystem. The sport comes with a small white pedestal on which you will need to stability RFID-enabled animal collectible figurines. Once the animals are positioned on the stand, they seem on a Bluetooth-linked cellphone or pill display screen. Each animal has a unique level worth, relying on how arduous it’s to make part of your balancing act.

It goes deeper, although, by letting you crossbreed to create precious new species or migrating animals between habitats (flip your octopus right into a land-dwelling “Rocktopus”!). Also, if one in all your animals turns into too precious, the opposite animals will start to lose worth as they method extinction, so a numerical stability should be struck in addition to a bodily one.

It’s a very accessible stacking sport for youthful children that solely will get extra rewarding as they perceive extra mechanics. My spouse and I even snuck in just a few rounds looking for intelligent, satisfying methods for animals to stability off one another. We’ve solely had the sport for every week and we’re already eyeing among the beautiful trying growth packs.

---

Designer of Super Meat Boy, The Binding of Isaac, and The Binding of Isaac: Four Souls

Dungeon Crawl Classics by Goodman Games is a hardcore throwback to old style Dungeons & Dragons. It shines vibrant when put subsequent to the 5e campaigns I’ve run the previous few years. The guidelines are harsh and life like however nonetheless open and enjoyable, and their modules are fingers down among the most inventive and galvanizing I’ve seen. One of the good components is almost all campaigns begin with a “meat grinder” funnel the place everybody begins with three to 4 degree zero widespread folks who undergo a hellish mini marketing campaign the place only some survive. This is what provides your character backstory and life by being a kind of few, pushed to show right into a hero out of your expertise.

I’m at present operating a marketing campaign for a sister system known as Mutant Crawl Classics that’s very gonzo, 70’s, psychedelic, post-apocalyptic madness. I might go on for days describing what the gamers have gone by, however let’s simply say they spent final session making a skateboard and amassing eyelashes from large boneless disembodied head blobs shortly after popping a boil stuffed with fetal scorpion/human hybrids and getting some candy radioactive tramp stamps!

Goodman Games is superb, and I extremely advocate them.

---

Voice actor, co-founder of Critical Role

After a good friend started gushing over a boutique horror board sport known as Kingdom Death: Monster final 12 months, my vibrant want for remedy gaming led me to dive in HARD. The extraordinarily darkish, unsettling setting of the sport and the exploration of its mysteries is a scrumptious sluggish burn as you construct a society from scraps in a lightless hellscape, searching nightmarish monsters for assets so you possibly can increase your settlement with improvements, crafting, rules, or higher weapons to combat again the darkness. The narrative that’s born out of random or chosen occasions and expedition outcomes (each good and unhealthy) weaves an enchanting story of survival, tragedy, and perseverance within the face of rising, historic threats simply past your lantern gentle. Heroes you spend money on immediately befall horrible maiming or die, educating you to embrace change and adaptation whereas reminding you that the settlement’s survival is what really issues. And the miniatures/monster sculpts. THE SCULPTS ARE SECOND TO NONE. I. Love. This. Game.

If you will get previous/embrace the horny cheesecake depictions of among the people, and you’re keen on long-form, rules-heavy board gaming with tactical components and a darkish story, might you tumble into this obsession alongside me.

---

Freelance author, Polygon contributor

Admittedly late to the flock on this one, however Wingspan is my board sport of the 12 months. You play as a chook fanatic in search of to draw the perfect birds to your wildlife protect. Through rising your protect, you play chook playing cards, lay eggs, and achieve meals to assist your habitat thrive. For positive, it’s an engine-builder board sport however what you might be creating is one thing natural and quaint, as the top objective is to create a welcoming surroundings for birds to hunt and roost by scoring essentially the most factors.

Even with the aggressive facet, Wingspan is extremely humble with beautiful sport boards, intricate items, and a cube tray within the form of a birdhouse to embody the general theme. Combining the mix of strategic problem with an alluring backdrop, Wingspan encourages you to play by repeatedly to construct the perfect protect potential, unlocking numerous combos and sequences to get you there. Any board sport that comes with quasi-educational intentions wrapped in an enthralling aesthetic is bound to seize my consideration, and Wingspan managed it with great ease. If you take pleasure in video games reminiscent of Terraforming Mars or Gizmos, you might be sure to like this and are available away with some nice avian trivia as a bonus.

---

Co-founder, Duncan Rhodes Painting Academy

Photo: Duncan Rhodes

One of my favorite miniature video games this 12 months has positively been The Elder Scrolls: Call to Arms by Modiphius Entertainment, a unbelievable skirmish-level sport with a heavy emphasis on a story expertise. It permits for regular play in opposition to an opponent or solo play in opposition to the sport itself and this, together with the discharge of extra factions and the Stormcloak Rebellion marketing campaign e-book over the previous couple of months, has brought on me to spend so much of time portray up new surroundings and characters in order that I can recreate Skyrim on my tabletop!

The core system is straightforward with layers added on prime which might be very intelligent of their use of components from the online game collection, and anybody who has hung out adventuring on the planet of Tamriel will instantly acknowledge the icons and talents on the varied playing cards, tokens, and rule books. You may even do the dreaded sneak assault archery which, when timed appropriately, might be devastating! If you wish to play a wargame with one in all its ft planted firmly in role-playing sport territory, then that is one to take a look at.

---

Film and TV editor, Polygon

In a typical 12 months, I would go to half a dozen gaming conventions and check out two or three dozen new indie tabletop RPGs, typically run by their builders at Games on Demand or First Look occasions. With gaming conventions so scaled down today, or moved on-line, I’ve had a lot much less alternative to get launched to new small-press video games, and it’s been fairly isolating. Which is why I’ve actually loved being invited to play Stonetop, a fresh-off-the-Kickstarter RPG about heroic fantasy adventures in a small city.

From the preliminary description, I used to be anticipating an especially low-key fireplace sport the place our characters is perhaps monitoring down misplaced sheep or coping with the occasional inimical touring stranger. But the setup for this sport is remarkably wealthy and in depth, the lore and mythology are in depth, and even the outline of our characters’ little hometown was full of memorable story hooks and implied horrors. For one thing meant to be small-scale and intimate, it definitely has the texture of an epic sport, with a software set designed to encourage participant creativity and funding from session zero, and all kinds of potential arcs constructed into the world. I used to be an instantaneous fan.

---

Game designer, inaugural Diana Jones Emerging Designer winner

I favor tactility and open-ended storytelling in my video games, and so it’s no marvel that Shing Yin Khor’s memento sport A Mending was one in all my favourite titles of 2021. The premise is that you’ve got parted from an previous good friend; after they name for you after a few years, you resolve to embark on the lengthy journey to reunite with them. Your character’s travels by a quietly fantastical land are guided by a deck of immediate playing cards, and the sport is performed by embroidering a map documenting your approach. The rulebook is enchanting and succinctly written, offering gamers with sufficient info to scaffold their expertise however leaving loads of room for them to create a narrative wholly their very own. At the top, you should have a singular memento crafted by your personal hand to conjure reminiscences of your quest lengthy after it’s ended.

---

Charlie Theel

Freelance author, Polygon contributor

Coming out of isolation there was one sport we wished to play and re-unite over. Oath: Chronicles of Empire and Exile from Leder Games and designer Cole Wehrle is a mesmerizing and wealthy tapestry of oral and written historical past in board sport type. Ostensibly it’s a wargame with gamers vying over management of a kingdom, however that’s actually simply the floor of Oath.

Amid the altering victory circumstances and uneven pursuits, you’re actually in battle over the narrative. You’re combating over the proper to rule, however extra importantly to manage our shared remembrance. A big ingredient of the expertise is within the victor jotting down just a few traces in a leather-based sure tome to commemorate the sport, a blurb we are able to mirror on years from now and reminisce about fallen empires and shattered goals. In this fashion the sport evolves over time, embracing our friendship and bitterness and leaving us with one thing greater than once we got here.

---

Scott ‘Miniac’ Walter

YouTuber and miniature painter

As somebody who’s excited about miniature conflict video games, I’m an enormous fan of crunchy rulesets. I like a board sport that it’s important to schedule time for as a result of it takes so lengthy to complete. Scythe ticks these containers fairly handily. However, it’s not difficult to make a sport that retains you up till 3:00 am leafing by a rulebook. The actual trick is to make the sport itself good which Scythe additionally nails!

The sport has a number of replay worth in all of the other ways you possibly can rating factors. After ending our first playthrough, all I wished to do was play once more to check out new methods. You actually really feel such as you’re rising an empire with all of the choices accessible to you. I cherished how as you upgraded your budding nation, you eliminated tokens from one spot in your board that had been beforehand protecting up the improve you unlocked, to then cowl up the price of an motion elsewhere in your board. Not solely does this make sense contemplating what an improve does typically, it reuses the sport piece, and tracks the ever-changing prices of your motion. I’m an enormous fan of that sort of intelligent effectivity.

---

Senior editor, Waypoint

Affliction: Salem 1692 takes a ton of acquainted board and card sport mechanics, wedges all of them into an elaborate-but-thematically-perfect “screw your neighbor” employee placement sport, and finally ends up being a surprisingly enjoyable and chaotic sport in regards to the Salem witch trials. It has change into a go-to sport for my Masshole buddies and I each autumn, a sport that we tried out for fun 4 years in the past so we might drink and misquote The Crucible and which has now change into a real favourite.

Affliction is a sport a couple of city going mad with paranoia, jealousy, and worry. The thought is that every participant belongs to both the extra mercantile Salem Town and the agricultural Village, and can do their finest to guard members of their neighborhood whereas taking down their persecutors within the rival neighborhood. Players can recruit historic characters to their board and use their particular skills to hold out particular or supercharged actions. However, those self same characters are targets for the opposite neighborhood, and the wealthier they’re, the extra they’re value as an arrest when the sport ends because the colonial authorities lastly shut down the witch hunt. There are additionally hidden bonus factors in play as every participant carries “grievances” with them that make some characters extraordinarily precious targets for the endgame scoring, getting at this notion of the witch trials as a technique to train bitter neighborly rivalries.

It’s actually too chaotic a sport for me to ever really feel like I’ve an excellent deal with on it. Deploying governor’s pardons, seizing the primary transfer within the flip order, investing in constructing accusations in opposition to characters or taking the shortcut supplied by doubtful “spectral evidence” is all enjoyable to fiddle with, but it surely additionally signifies that Affliction feels extra like a melee than a sport of cautious technique.

But you already know, that’s a part of what makes it a enjoyable various to plenty of the extra logical, optimization-focused employee placement video games I spend time with. It additionally feels proper for the subject material: it is a neighborhood that will get ripped aside by greed and self-righteousness armed with superstition and legalism. The approach Affliction turns intricate guidelines and mechanics to a maelstrom of small-town violence makes it a dependable favourite.